Wednesday, March 6, 2013

alchemist discussion questions- part 1


I know that this is a Greek myth about a very handsome man called narcissus who was very vain. He was so vain that he stared at his refection all day long in a lake just looking at himself. Over time he fell deeply in love with himself. One day, when he couldn't stand to just look at his beauty anymore, he dove into the lake, and drowned to death.
The traditional interpretation is that narcissus deserved to die because of his vanity. He was self-centered was only able to be happy when thinking about himself.  This story is meant to be a warning to other people, to not be vain like narcissus, because it only leads to trouble.
I think that the relationship between the re-telling of narcissus  and the alchemist is about finding people to help you. The lake and narcissus made each other happy. They may have been vain and imperfect things but they brought each other joy. They saw their own beauty reflected on other surface and only then were able to see themselves. I think it also has to do with the soul of the world. When you stare into the soul of the world, it stares right back at you. And if you hurt yourself you hurt the soul of the world with you. Everything is connected and your decisions have an impact on every other thing. As the king said “there is a force that wants you to realize your personal legend” (29). The reason that that force is around, is because when you achieve your personal legend you help yourself, also help the soul of the world. Many people help the shepherded along in his story and help to direct his quest, the king, the gypsy, the store keeper.  Even the thief steals from him helps him to be stronger because only after being stolen from he realized that he could “”choose between thinking of himself as the poor victim of a thief and as an adventurer looking for treasure.” (42)  

The boy comes from Spain but most of the book takes place in Egypt. I think one of the reasons that the author did this was to help signal a big change. He had to re-learn everything he knew and adapt to the new place. Egypt is also a romanticized land. Of impossible feats, the pyramids, of erratic floods that can destroy everything you have, the Nile, and of great, long lost, treasures. Spain is viewed as a more plushy country. It has fantastic weather and beautiful women. The contrast between Spain and Egypt also highlights just how much he gave up for his personal legend.

            Her introduction brings up his role in society. “if you know how to read, why are you just a shepherd” (6) the words “just a shepherd” show a lot. It shows that he is low on the totem pole in society. It also shows about how if he really wanted to, he could have done something others would have labeled as “more important” or gain him more respect or money. He is a shepherd because he loves to travel. It shows that he is already in touch with his personal legend a lot more than many other people are. He has already begun to do things just for the sake of making himself happy. Which, as the king points out, is very rare.

The boy’s original motive was to become rich. He finds the treasure. The story would most likely feel a little incomplete without it. I think the fact that he travels all the way too Egypt then all the way back helps you to understand that it isn't about the money, it’s about the journey you take. Of course the money doesn't hurt, but I think that if the boy had come to the end of his travels, only to find nothing, I don’t think he would be very disappointed.

No comments:

Post a Comment